The AR-15 Case Just Got Its Other Side — And the Argument Is Already Set
The Supreme Court fight over AR-15 bans now has both sides on the table. Cook County, Illinois, and the state of Connecticut filed their briefs on October 21 defending their bans on AR-15-platform and similar semiautomatic rifles, in Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins. The Court will hear argument on December 2, and a decision is expected by June 2027.
Their argument is worth understanding on its own terms, because it will be the argument gun owners hear for the next eight months. Cook County says the relative popularity of a weapon does not insulate it from regulation, and that AR-15s are “not in common use” for any purpose that would protect them. Connecticut and Cook County both lean on the same core idea: these rifles are unusually dangerous, so a ban is justified even if millions of Americans own them.
The other side of that coin is the number itself. Gun groups count somewhere between 20 and 40 million of these rifles in American hands — the most commonly owned rifles in the country. The challengers’ argument, backed by the U.S. Solicitor General, is simple: a rifle that common is, by definition, in common use, and Heller and Bruen already rejected the kind of interest-balancing that would let a government ban a popular firearm because it considers it dangerous.
Why this matters beyond Illinois and Connecticut: this ruling will land on assault-weapons laws in about a dozen states and the District of Columbia. Whatever the Court decides will set the terms for every one of those fights.
Here’s my take. I’ve spent years teaching people to separate what a gun does from what people fear it does, and this case is that lesson at the highest level. A rifle doesn’t become “unusually dangerous” because a legislature calls it that — and it doesn’t become unprotected because it’s popular. The Court is going to decide whether “common use” means what it says, or whether a government can define its way around it.
So here’s my question for you: if the Court says a rifle owned by tens of millions of Americans still isn’t “in common use,” what do you think that phrase will ever protect?